BREA, Orange County — November 12, 2026. A plan to bring a Costco store to the east side of Brea has become a dispute about transparency, public money and private development. Residents organized as Brea4All have sued city officials over the way public records were produced during negotiations for a 50-year economic development agreement. The group says it received incomplete and hard-to-read text messages between a senior city official and developer Dwight Manley. City officials dispute the implication that they failed to provide substantial records, while Manley says the development agreement was proper. Brea News is examining the documents and will publish dated responses as they become available.
What the lawsuit actually alleges
According to Voice of OC's November 6 reporting based on the petition, Brea4All filed a writ-of-mandate proceeding on September 29 in Orange County Superior Court against the city and Community Development Director/Assistant City Manager Jason Killebrew. Its complaint concerns production of text-message conversations involving Killebrew and Manley. The group alleges missing portions, absent timestamps and PDF screenshots out of chronological order. The lawsuit asks for records and litigation costs, including attorney fees. Filing a case is not a court ruling that a public-records law was violated.
How much sales tax is involved?
Voice of OC reports that the economic agreement, connected to the proposed Costco at 200 and 250 South Kraemer Boulevard, could send an estimated $77 million in future sales-tax revenue to the developer and his trust over 50 years, compared with approximately $50 million projected for the city and around $7 million for the senior center. These are reported forecasts over a long period, not cash already paid to anyone. Tax collections depend on the store opening, actual sales and agreement conditions. The developer would not receive the entirety of the city's taxes from other businesses.
What the city and developer said
City public information officer Liz Pharis told Voice of OC that Brea had already provided more than 15,000 pages in response to the relevant records requests and offered no new substantive comment about the lawsuit. Manley said his investments, which he described as exceeding $100 million alongside Costco, make the project and its claimed long-term community benefits possible. He maintained that the process was lawful and overseen by attorneys. These are their positions; they have not been rejected by a court in the records cited here.
Why residents want the messages in order
The residents' group says records show contacts and negotiations earlier than the formal public economic-development agreement. It argues that properly organized, complete public correspondence is needed to assess how the agreement developed. That concern does not establish a secret unlawful deal or that any official personally profited. The earlier September Voice of OC report shows that the records dispute preceded the lawsuit.
EDITORIAL FOLLOW-UP — November 12, 2026: Brea News has sent a request for comment and public-document links to the City of Brea's public information officer and City Clerk's Office. We asked about the executed tax agreement, estimated financial terms, production of relevant message records and pending court proceedings. No new response has been received for this inquiry as of this dated update. Statements from the city, developer or residents will be identified by source and date if obtained.
Five questions Brea News is pursuing
- Can the city publish a complete index of the responsive electronic messages, including preserved timestamps, lawful redactions and any explanation of gaps?
- What exact forecast assumptions produced the reported 50-year figures, and how sensitive are they to sales volume or a delayed opening?
- Which council meetings, staff reports and legal reviews authorized the agreement and the public-revenue allocation?
- Do the city and developer have a publicly available written explanation of the project's upfront infrastructure and acquisition costs?
- What is the next court hearing, and can the clerk supply public filings and any orders without exposing private data?
What happens next: Voice of OC reports a December 3 status conference at the North Justice Center in Fullerton. That is a procedural court date, not a scheduled verdict on whether anyone broke the law. Brea News invites the city, developer and residents to provide documents or on-the-record corrections at california58com@gmail.com. Sources: Voice of OC November 6 investigation and reported lawsuit; prior public-records dispute. We have not independently obtained a court-certified docket or all cited message files; allegations and projections are attributed accordingly.
Support Brea News
Choose how to support Brea News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “Brea News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from Brea News
- Brea City Council: Hupp, Stewart and Vargas Lead Five-Candidate Contest for Three Seats →
- Hupp, Stewart and Vargas lead preliminary Brea council count →
- Arovista Park Modernization Has No Confirmed Reopening Date as Brea Works Toward Late 2026 →
- Brea Households Get Three Free Bulky-Item Pickups Annually, With Up to 20 Items Each →
- Brea's Standard Residential Trash Rate Rose to $34.34 a Month for 2026–27 →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.